Back to scorecard
CACR 10 Failed

Ban Income Tax Forever

158 Democrats voted AGAINST banning income taxes

What This Bill Does

CACR 10 was a proposed constitutional amendment to permanently ban a state income tax in New Hampshire. It would have required a two-thirds supermajority to ever impose one. New Hampshire has never had an income tax, and the "NH Advantage" — no income tax, no sales tax — is one of the defining features of the state. The amendment received 194 votes (55%), but fell short of the 236 (60%) needed for a constitutional amendment.

The Full Story

The timeline tells the whole story. On March 3, 2026, Andru Volinsky — a former Democratic gubernatorial candidate — unveiled his "3-3 Tax Savings Plan": a 3% income tax on all personal income plus a $3-per-$1,000 statewide property tax. The plan would raise an estimated $2 billion per year.

That same day, House Minority Leader Alexis Simpson (D-Exeter) declared: "Democrats will not support an income tax." Two days later, on March 5, CACR 10 came to a vote. The result: 190 Republicans voted YES. 158 Democrats voted NO.

Only 4 Democrats — Dale Girard, Patrick Long, Linda Ryan, and Jennifer Mandelbaum — broke ranks to vote for the ban. When asked if the income tax was truly "off the table" for Democrats, Volinsky responded: "Some people think it's off the table." Rep. Thomas Oppel (D-Canaan) was more direct at the press conference: "We need to start the conversation about how we're going to adequately fund state services.

The people with the most need to pay their fair share." Connecticut is the cautionary tale: in 1991, it introduced a "modest" 1.5% income tax. Today it's 6.99%, property taxes are the 3rd highest in America, and the state is losing population. Massachusetts introduced a "temporary" 3% sales tax in 1966 — it's still there at 6.25%, 59 years later, and was made permanent after just one year.

Party Breakdown

Republicans

190 Yea

0 Nay · 24 Absent/NV

Democrats

4 Yea

158 Nay · 15 Absent/NV

What Voters Think

71% of NH voters oppose a state income tax — including 47% of Democrats

Saint Anselm College Survey Center, March 2026 (n=1,491)

Back to full scorecard